Genre Conventions.
1. In the first 4 paragraphs, Thomas Carty cites several authors that provide background for article and topic of JFK’s Catholicism. Additionally, Carty cites his research on JFK’s religion throughout the entirety of the journal.
2. The rhetorical structure is set up to present the argument made by other scholars, then the thesis and then present the information and facts on “the catholic question”.
Carty makes many connections between the sources to defend his point.
3. The thesis statement is “This article explains how Kennedy's 1960 campaign prompted liberals to extend the principle of religious liberty to American Catholics. Despite strong opposition, Kennedy was able to win the Democratic presidential nomination by successfully distancing himself from unpopular Catholic political positions and strongly asserting his commitment to separation of church and state, thus allaying libertarian concerns. Once the nomination was secured, party solidarity silenced most remaining liberal critics in order to ensure a Democratic victory.” and is following Carty’s background citations. The author also makes sure to point out, prior to the thesis, that they will not be focuses on the typical POV the controversy is faced with.
4. “The Catholic Question” uses a good mix of primary and secondary sources. Some of the primary sources include ‘artifacts’ such as a handwritten letter, as well propaganda from the time of 1960 campaign. The secondary sources are similar pieces to the article that are written in hindsight, utilizing the data and passing of time that support the outlandishness of JFK’s nomination and victory as the only Catholic to serve as President of the United States.
5. This article is subtly based on arguments, as the topic is very political. The counterarguments are assessed and addressed throughout the article. The counterarguments include the conservative view vs liberal and the belief that his religion was a non-issue.
6. The primary audience is likely those who study American History and Politics or people who are fans of John Fitzgerald Kennedy. There could be a target audience for Catholics, however it focuses more on the impact Catholicism had on the election of Kennedy rather than Kennedy as a Catholic; therefore it is unlikely that is the primary audience.
7. Pathos is used in the article to draw emotional responses from the audience triggering political emotions and feelings. The article focuses more on ethos and logos more than pathos.
8. I think something unique and interesting about the journal article is the perspective it is written from, as the author stated, is very much different than how is it typically written.
Comments